Is Alexander the Great Truly Great? [Serena]


How does this man deserve to go down in history?

The truth is that, Alexander the Great is one of the most famous people in history, but why do we know him as Alexander the Great?  Is he truly great?  Yes, he is, but let me give you some background information first.  Alexander was born in 365 B.C.E. in Macedonia.  After conquering nearby Greek city-states, his father, Philip, planned on attacking Persia.  Philip was soon assassinated and Alexander inherited the kingdom.  Alexander conquered Persia and replaced Darius on the throne.  However, he still pushed on and conquered even more land.  Over the years, he started to suffer severe wounds that had weakened his health and became ill.  Soon after, he died.  Since Alexander had not named an heir, the generals started to fight.  However, the generals split up the land and the kingdom started to fall apart. 

Reasons why Alexander the Great is great:
  • He showed kindness to those whose lands he conquered
  • He was brave, dauntless, amd made many great achievements
  • He was generous to his followers and others
  • He was intelligent and used strategies to conquer a lot of land

Conquering land is tough… well… from what I’ve read.  People have to kill each other and try to win the battle that they are fighting.  However, sometimes people are lucky, and their enemies just surrender, but that’s past the point.  Very rarely, though, does the king, ruler, or whatever they are called, keep some of their enemies safe, on purpose, when everyone else is being killed.  Well, that might not be that rare, depending on what you’ve heard or read.
Nonetheless, Alexander the Great did exactly that, well, okay, maybe not exactly, but you get the point.
According to an excerpt from the book Alexander of Macedon by Peter Green:
 “When the last organized resistance was broken, Alexander’s [soldiers] ranged through the city on a ferocious manhunt….Alexander had ordered that all [except] those who sought sanctuary [safety in the temple] were to be slain, and his commands were executed with savage relish.”
This shows that although he killed a lot of people, he still saved lots of people as well, and it also shows that he was kind.
            Sometimes a man who thinks of himself as a god thinks of only himself, but not Alexander.  According to the Legend of the Helmet by Lucius Flavius Arrianus, Alexander’s army was marching across a desert of sand.  Alexander was extremely thirsty, just like everyone else, but he continued to march.  A small group of men whom had gone off looking for water found some.  They poured it into a helmet and gave it to him.  Alexander, in full view of his troops, took the helmet and poured all of the water onto the ground.  This proves that he was kind and not selfish, for he had thought that if no one else could drink water, then he wouldn’t either.  This also shows that he was kind.

It took Alexander 11 years to build his empire, and in that 11 years, he made a lot of great and amazing achievements, according to Alexander’s Legacy chart by the DBQ Project.  
Let’s take a look at some :
  • He conquered most of the world that was known to him
  • The size of his empire was about 2 million square miles
  • Alexander spread Greek thoughts and idea
  • The length of the Hellenistic Period in the Middle East and western Asia was about 300 years
  • He founded 70 cities
  • Greek remained the official language of Jordan for about 1,000 years

            However, these are just a few of the reasons why Alexander was amazing.  Additionally, he was brave, dauntless, and generous to his followers, as said in an excerpt of the book In the Footsteps if Alexander the Great by Michael Wood.

Alexander was so successful was because he was a wise leader who knew how to win battles.  He knew that he should take out the people who would be a threat to him.

According to The Campaigns of Alexander by Lucius Flavius Arrianus:

“He realized that he could not cross at the point where Porus was
encamped - his elephants were too numerous…. When Alexander saw this, he [decided to] move his troops in all different directions so that Porus would keep puzzled…. At night he would take most of his cavalry to various points along the river bank where he would create a clamour, raise the war cry and produce all other such noises as would come from men preparing to cross the river.”

This proves that, if there was a problem, Alexander knew how to get around it.  It also shows that Alexander was intelligent and wise because he used strategies to win a fight or battle when he knew that there was an obstacle in his way.

You are truly great, Alexander.






How Alexander has ripped us off for more than 2,000 years [Aryan]


Image result for alexander the great killing with a spear  
In modern times, we refer to 10-50 people dying a massacre.  We also call their killers, evil murderers.  It turns out though, that if, and only if you kill 100,000 people, you will become an idol for those who strive for greatness.

The opinion of greatness is different for different people.  Most great people have the characteristics of:
  • Forgiveness
  • Leadership
  • Courage
  • Humility
  • Concern for others
  • Concern for others
  • Concern for others
I put “concern for others” many times because, in my opinion, people become great by doing something for people and making their lives better.

Alexander’s father had Macedonia and Greece under his control before Alexander was born.  Alexander wanted to expand his empire, so he turned his eyes to Persia.

Alexander went on this expedition and conquered 2,000,000 square miles and kill 100,000 people1.  He would of conquered further into India  and killed more people but his army forced him to turn back. This is so terrible because you’re supposed to be helping people not kill and rule over them.  He likes to kill and harm people.  So much for “concern for others”!
While Alexander was going on his journey to conquer every piece of land he could see, he came across the island of Tyre.  They stopped Alexander for 7 months until he inevitably got through.  What do you think he did?
a.             He forgave everyone
b.            He killed 7,000 Tyrians 2
c.             30,000 survivors were sold into slavery 2
d.            2,000 men of military age were crucified 2
e.              Option b,c, and d
Being able to forgive is a mark of true greatness.  People have forgiven those who have killed their families.  So if you’re so great, why can’t you forgive those that don’t want to be conquered by you?

No one likes arrogant people.  No one.  Alexander was arrogant.  He encouraged the Egyptians to call him G-d.  Then he required the Greeks to call him the son of Zeus 3.  This started when Alexander was young when he was taught by Aristotle who encouraged that he himself was a G-d.  Being humble means that no matter how great you are you think of yourself normally.  Another he missed out on.

Being bloodthirsty, arrogant, and not being able to forgive will lead you to the opposite of greatness.  Please, stop believing the legends and myths and look at the facts.  Alexander is NOT GREAT.










1 Alexander’s Legacy Chart
2 Alexander of Macedon by Peter Green
3 History Alive textbook